Reforming of electrolytic capacitors with automatic regenerator

Hello everyone. Today I want to share with you a recent experience that led me to pick up again a project I had built as far back as 10 years ago, when I was still just a simple hobbyist. Recently, I was contacted by an electronic components wholesaler who needed to reform a fairly large batch of Nichicon electrolytic capacitors that had remained in storage.

These capacitors had to be reformed before they could be sold, and the batch contained as many as 500 pieces. They were large capacitors rated at 3900uF 500 volts, so my old regenerator needed a few modifications to handle them properly. It was also a pleasure to dig this old project out of my archive and work again on the article I had published on the site many years ago.

I still remember the excitement I felt when I saw my regenerator working well the first time I built it. This time, however, the challenge was different, because I had to deal with a large number of big capacitors with demanding characteristics. For this reason, I decided to improve and optimize the device, making the system more precise and efficient and adding a few more checks during the reforming process.

What does reforming a capacitor mean?

Reforming electrolytic capacitors is a practice used to bring capacitors that have remained inactive for a long time back to normal operating condition. When a new capacitor, or in any case one that is still good, sits unused for years, it may lose its operating characteristics because of deterioration of the dielectric layer. Before putting it back into service, it is therefore advisable to “wake it up” with a reforming process, applying voltage gradually and limiting the charging current. In this way the internal oxide layer is properly rebuilt, and this is exactly where the term “reforming” comes from.

Reforming therefore consists of applying a controlled voltage to the capacitor, with limited current, for a time that is not predetermined, until the component reaches its rated voltage with a very low leakage current, ideally close to zero. It is important that the current be limited, because charging it too aggressively could cause internal discharges or even damage the capacitor.

Through reforming, the goal is to recover the capacitor’s correct behavior, bringing it as close as possible to its normal operating values. It should be remembered, however, that this procedure is useful only when the component has simply lost efficiency because of long inactivity. If the capacitor is already compromised, or has reached end of life, reforming cannot work miracles and the component must be replaced.

The regenerator

Electrolytic capacitor reforming can be done in various ways, for example by using a variac or a series resistor to charge the capacitor slowly. These are simple methods, but they also have limits. The times can become very variable, current control is not always adequate and, if care is not taken, the component may be stressed unnecessarily.

To overcome these limits, I preferred to use a circuit with its own operating logic. This circuit applies trains of fast but non-destructive pulses to the capacitor, continuously monitoring the absorbed current. Every time the current exceeds a certain set value, for example 10mA, the circuit introduces a pause between one pulse train and the next, giving the capacitor the time it needs to reform its internal elements.

The process continues until the capacitor reaches the desired rated voltage with absorption close to zero. At that point the capacitor is discharged through a pair of light bulbs. Before the June 2023 modification, a resistor was simply used for the discharge, but with large capacitors like the ones I now have to reform, the heat dissipation problem became annoying. For this reason, I adopted a simple but effective solution, that is, two 3 candlepower 230 volt bulbs, the kind used in refrigerators, connected in series.

This system makes it possible to reduce reforming times and adapts fairly well to the behavior of the individual capacitor. In practice, it is the capacitor itself, through its absorption, that sets the pace of the process. From the tests I had already carried out before 2013, pulse-train reforming had proven to be as effective as the constant-current method, but noticeably faster. That is why I continued along this path.

An essential instrument for those who repair vintage radios and tube amplifiers

This instrument proves very useful for those involved in the repair and restoration of vintage radios and tube amplifiers. When trying to bring equipment back into operation after it has sat unused for decades, it is often necessary to reform the old electrolytic capacitors, at least when they are still recoverable. Thanks to this device, I have managed to bring capacitors from the 1940s back into service, allowing the proper restart of historic equipment. In the case of audio amplifiers, preserving the old electrolytics, when possible, can also help maintain the original sonic character of the equipment, avoiding unnecessarily invasive replacements.

The construction

I therefore set to work carrying out some experiments on a breadboard using a Picaxe 18M2 microcontroller as the circuit’s processing unit.

I developed an analog stage using a flyback transformer as the central element. To build it, I used a small output transformer recovered from a scrapped tube radio, connected in reverse. The power FET is driven on the secondary side, while the high voltage is taken from the primary. The Picaxe 18M2 microcontroller is responsible for generating PWM pulse trains to control the FET and for measuring both the voltage across the capacitor during charging and the absorbed current.

In practice, the flyback is able to generate more than 700 volts DC at no load, with a short-circuit current of 30mA. Naturally, the MCU limits the maximum voltage reached by the capacitor during charging and, above all, limits the average absorbed current to 10mA. The amplitude and current of the pulses remain constant, while the duration of the pulse trains and the pause between one train and the next change. This method, which on paper may seem a bit aggressive, works very well in practice. I managed to reform several capacitors picked at random from the “cadaver” box, including a couple that had not recovered with the old constant-current regenerator, and in fairly short times.

Let us take a look at the construction of the device. I grabbed a random transformer from the pile of salvaged parts…

During operation, the transformer I had used was noisy. To solve the problem, I decided to immerse it in wax so as to silence it as much as possible. After all, the poor transformer was not born to handle 15 watts of modulated square waves, with currents reaching almost 1A on the secondary. It was a simple remedy, but it worked well.

I was surprised by how effective the wax immersion was in reducing the noise emitted by the circuit. The result was so good that the noise practically disappeared. Below you can see a photo of the circuit assembled on a 1000-hole breadboard before being mounted in the final enclosure. As you can see, the LEDs are connected provisionally only for testing.

Here is the schematic, click to enlarge:

Click here to download the schematic in PDF format: rigeneratore.pdf

Below I report the firmware source in basic. Yes, it is true, I do not particularly like Basic and today I prefer Arduino and the C language.

; Sorgente del rigeneratore di condensatori, versione 1.1v, www.sb-lab.eu, questo programma e' sottoposto a licenza GPL v.2

#no_data
#picaxe 18m2

setfreq m16 ; frequenza della CPU a 16mhz

symbol pwmdri = B.3
symbol caricaled = C.3
symbol volt_pin = B.2
symbol tensione = b0
symbol preset = b1
symbol speed = b2
symbol corrente = b3
symbol ritardo = b4
symbol volano = b5
symbol noblinc = b6
symbol nvolte = b7
symbol pin150 = pinB.4
symbol pin200 = pinB.5
symbol pin250 = pinB.6
symbol pin300 = pinB.7
symbol pin350 = pinC.6
symbol pin400 = pinC.7
symbol pin450 = pinC.0
symbol pin500 = pinC.1
symbol rl = C.2
symbol pulsante = pinC.5
symbol amp_pin = B.1
symbol low_led = B.0

; routines per la taratura della parte analogica (pin500 e pin450 collegati al +5v)
if pin500 = 1 and pin450 = 1 then
	goto tara
endif

; stato di riposo, attende che venga premuto il tasto start/stop
main:
setint off ; disattiva l'interrupt
gosub scarica
gosub hv_off
low caricaled
let nvolte = 0
wait 3
do
if pulsante = 1 then
	exit
endif
loop

; Legge quale tensione e' stata selezionata, va alla subroutines di preset, poi avvia il loop rigenera
seleziona:
wait 3

setint %00100000,%00100000 ; setta l'interrupt che permette di fare lo stop immediato del processo di rigenerazione in qualsiasi momento venga premuto il tasto start/stop

do
if pin150 = 1 then
	gosub v150
elseif pin200 = 1 then
	gosub v200
elseif pin250 = 1 then
	gosub v250
elseif pin300 = 1 then
	gosub v300
elseif pin350 = 1 then
	gosub v350
elseif pin400 = 1 then
	gosub v400
elseif pin450 = 1 then
	gosub v450
elseif pin500 = 1 then
	gosub v500
else
	gosub v100
endif
gosub rigenera
loop

; inizia il loop di rigenerazione del condensatore
rigenera:
let noblinc = 0 ; serve a evitare il blinc del led giallo (basso assorbimento) nei primi istanti di carica
let volano = 150 ; serve a dare una prima botta di carica che dura tot millisecondi (tanti quanti il valore specificato)
		 ; prima del primo campionamento degli adc, per evitare che il processo si fermi con un'errore di condensatore non connesso

do
let corrente = 0 ; azzera i registri corrente e tensione
let tensione = 0
low low_led ; spegne l'indicazione di basso assorbimento
high caricaled ; accende il led che indica l'inizio della carica del condensatore da rigenerare
gosub hv_on ; attiva l'alta tensione
pause volano ; fa una pausa, con l'alta tensione attiva, prima di campionare tensione e corrente, il valore viene cambiato con quello del preset alla fine del primo loop

readadc amp_pin, corrente ; campiona i valori analogici di corrente e tensione con l'adc a 8 bit
readadc volt_pin,tensione

if corrente > 100 then ; se la corrente supera il valore impostato spegne il generatore di alta tensione
	gosub hv_off
	pause 5
elseif corrente < 50 then ; se la corrente e' al di sotto del valore impostato entra nello stato di errore condensatore non connesso
	gosub hv_off
	low caricaled
	gosub scarica
	do
		high low_led
		wait 1
		low low_led
		wait 1
	loop
elseif corrente < 95 and noblinc > 5 then ; se la corrente e' al di sotto del valore impostato accende il led giallo che segnala il basso assorbimento, ma solo dopo 5 cicli del loop
	high low_led
elseif tensione > preset and corrente > 50 then ; se il valore di tensione misurato e' superiore al preset e la corrente assorbita non e' al di sotto del valore specificato termina il ciclo con la scarica del condensatore
	gosub hv_off
	wait 5
	low caricaled
	gosub scarica
	return
endif

let noblinc = noblinc +1 ; incrementa il registro antiblincamento
let volano = ritardo ; al termine del primo loop imposta il valore del registro volano dal valore lungo necessario al primo campionamento a quello corto impostato nel preset
loop

; preset per le varie tensioni

v100:
let preset = 66
let speed = 2
let ritardo = 5
return

v150:
let preset = 100
let speed = 0
let ritardo = 2
return

v200:
let preset = 135
let speed = 0
let ritardo = 2
return

v250:
let preset = 165
let speed = 0
let ritardo = 2
return

v300:
let preset = 195
let speed = 0
let ritardo = 2
return

v350:
let preset = 218
let speed = 1
let ritardo = 5
return

v400:
let preset = 237
let speed = 1
let ritardo = 5
return

v450:
let preset = 246
let speed = 1
let ritardo = 5
return

v500:
let preset = 254
let speed = 1
let ritardo = 5
return

; routines di scarica del condensatore
scarica:
low low_led
; attivo il rele' che scarica il condensatore sulla lampadina
high rl
; controllo la tensione fino a che si approssima a zero quindi disattivo il rele'
do
  wait 2
  readadc volt_pin,tensione
loop while tensione != 0
low rl
if nvolte = 1 then ; se sono stati fatti 2 cicli di scarica si ferma e da segnale di completo
	do
	high caricaled
	pause 250
	low caricaled
	pause 250
	loop
endif
let nvolte = nvolte + 1
return

; routines di taratura del trimmer di misura della tensione
tara:
setint %00100000,%00100000
do
gosub v500
gosub hv_on
pause 100
readadc volt_pin,tensione

if tensione > preset then
	gosub hv_off
	pause 5
endif
loop

; attiva il segnale pwm per la generazione dell'alta tensione con frequenze e dutycicle diversi in base al valore impostato nel preset.
hv_on:
if speed = 0 then
	pwmout pwmdri,66,187 ; 15khz 70%
elseif speed = 1 then
	pwmout pwmdiv4, pwmdri, 249, 800 ; 1khz 80%
elseif speed = 2 then
	pwmout pwmdiv16, B.3, 124, 250 ; 500hz 50%
endif
return

; routines di spegnimento dell'alta tensione
hv_off:
pwmout pwmdri,off
return

; routines dell'interrupt per lo stop rapido del ciclo di carica (resetta il chip).
interrupt:
reset 

IMPORTANT NOTE about the transformer: it is essential to understand that not all transformers are suitable for this circuit. To test the transformer and calibrate the trimmer that limits the voltage to 500 volts, I included a specific procedure in the microcontroller that works as follows: before powering up the circuit, the rotary switch that selects the various voltages must be disconnected and the two pins corresponding to the 450V and 500V steps of the selector must be connected to +5V. At that point the circuit is powered up. During startup, if the microcontroller finds these two pins high, it activates the high-voltage generator at maximum power, without current limiting.

At the transformer output, in place of the capacitor, a load resistor of EXACTLY 50k must be connected, capable of dissipating at least 5 watts for about ten seconds without overheating. In this configuration, the trimmer is adjusted until a voltage of 500 volts is measured across the resistor with a tester. If the voltage is much lower and cannot be increased, it is worth trying to reverse the secondary or primary leads of the transformer. Since the square waveform is asymmetrical, rectifying one half-wave rather than the other can produce significant differences. If even then the required voltage cannot be obtained, it simply means that transformer is not suitable for this circuit.

In the microcontroller program I included various presets corresponding to the different voltages to be generated, and each preset has a specific driving frequency. This choice came from a few considerations made during the development of the circuit.

The reference transformer I had used showed greater efficiency in power transfer, therefore voltage and current, at lower frequencies, around 1kHz. However, at that frequency the transformer made more noise and the power FET ran hotter. On the other hand, at higher frequencies, for example 15kHz, the mechanical vibration of the transformer decreased and the FET dissipated less, but the output voltage could not exceed 320 volts.

To work around this limitation, I therefore implemented different presets in the microcontroller. Each preset sets the parameters according to the desired voltage. For voltages between 150 and 300 volts, the circuit works at 15kHz with a duty cycle of 70%. For voltages between 350 and 500 volts, it works at 1kHz with a duty cycle of 80%. For the 100 volt preset, on the other hand, the circuit works at 500Hz with a duty cycle of 50%.

A note should be made about the 100 volt preset. Since the microcontroller works sequentially, sending a certain number of pulses to the capacitor before measuring voltage and current, with small-capacitance capacitors it happened that it could not stop the high voltage in time. As a result, at the moment of sampling, the voltage was almost always above 160 volts. To solve the problem I added a preset that would deliver less power with each individual pulse, so that, with smaller charging steps, the microcontroller would have time to intervene before exceeding 100 volts.

Even though the first calibration is done on a resistor, further adjustments can still be made to the trimmer afterward. Small corrections can be made using test capacitors in good condition that do not need reforming. It should be kept in mind, however, that with 500 volts at the output of the high-voltage circuit, 5 volts must be obtained at the output of the trimmer, no more, because the ADC cannot read higher voltages and because the 5.6 volt protection zener that protects the chip would come into operation.

In addition, it is possible to act on the value of the “preset” register to modify the voltage at which the microcontroller starts the discharge sequence. I set all voltages so that they exceed the desired maximum value by 5 or 10 volts, in order to ensure more complete capacitor reforming.

It may also be necessary to modify the frequencies and duty cycles set in the “hv_on:” routine if the transformer is changed. In that case, a few tests are needed to find the optimal values. The important thing is to make sure that the circuit can provide the required voltage with a current of 10mA, gradually increasing the value of the test resistors.

If the microcontroller should stop immediately after the first charging pulse, as indicated by the flashing LED that signals the capacitor is not connected, it is possible to act on the “ritardo” register in the presets. This register establishes the waiting time between enabling HV and sampling voltage and charging current. If the delay is too short compared with the frequency response of the high-voltage generator and the low-pass filters present at the output of the dividers, sampling may occur before a measurable voltage forms across the current sensing divider, made up of a 220 ohm resistor connected between ground and the negative terminal of the capacitor. In that case, the program may believe that no capacitor is connected and jump to the error routine.

A few tricks

Over the years I used this regenerator, I learned a few little tricks that might be useful to you. If you are reforming an old capacitor, for example one installed in a vintage amplifier or antique radio, and you notice that the voltage stops rising and stalls at a certain value, perhaps with slight warming of the capacitor after a few minutes, I suggest interrupting the process by pressing the start/stop button. Let a few hours pass and try again. Often, on the next cycle, the reforming completes without problems. If instead it always stops at the same voltage, then that capacitor should be considered no longer usable.

At the end of the reforming process it is always advisable to measure the capacitance and ESR of the capacitor to check whether the parameters are acceptable. For greater peace of mind, I also recommend a further reforming cycle after 24 hours. If the capacitor is truly in good condition, at that point it will charge quickly and effortlessly, almost like a new component. If, on the other hand, charging becomes slow again, something I have rarely seen but that can happen, the capacitor is not reliable and it is better to discard it. Naturally, if it shows electrolyte leakage, present or past, it must be thrown away without thinking twice.

Modification carried out in 2023 to handle very large capacitors

To solve the space problem inside the metal box, I chose a quick and very practical solution. I drilled two holes in the top of the enclosure and fixed two old salvaged lamp holders on top. The bulbs used have a nominal power of about 3 candlepower, roughly 3 watts. The solution is a bit funny, almost cartoon-like, but it allowed me to obtain a usable device without having to rebuild everything from scratch.

In the video below you can see the regenerator as it reaches the final stage of the reforming cycle of a large 3900uF 500 volt capacitor. Once reforming is completed, the capacitor is discharged into the bulbs, which in fact light up. Do not mind the voltmeter that occasionally drops to zero, sooner or later I will have to replace it…

The regenerator, in firmware version 1.1, performs two complete reforming cycles before stopping, signaling the end of the process with a rapid flashing of the red LED. It is essential to pay attention during operation, because potentially dangerous DC voltages are present across the capacitor and on the regenerator terminals themselves.

In the case of high-capacitance capacitors, like the one shown in the video, but also with smaller capacitors, a considerable amount of stored energy may be present, enough to be lethal to people and animals or to cause explosions in the event of accidental short circuits. In addition, direct current is much more dangerous than alternating current.

For this reason it is essential to equip the device with a voltmeter, so that the voltage across the capacitor can be monitored at all times, and to secure the capacitor safely, preventing any movement, rolling, or accidental fall.

Before touching the capacitor during reforming, it is always necessary to make sure that the regenerator is not in the charging phase and that the discharge has ended, checking that the voltage is close to zero or actually zero. In case of doubt about the charge state of the capacitor, it is advisable to check also with an external tester and discharge any residual charge with a capacitor discharger as described in the related article. It is important to underline that, if you decide to build this device, you assume all responsibility. It is therefore recommended to read carefully the disclaimer article before proceeding.

Continue reading...

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

How to build an “advanced” Variac for the laboratory

What is a variac?

A variac, also known as a variable autotransformer, is an electrical device used to regulate the output AC voltage in a continuous and controlled manner. Its construction is based on a single winding wrapped around a toroidal core made of ferromagnetic material. The output voltage is adjusted by means of a sliding contact or movable brush connected to the winding. By moving the contact along the winding, it is possible to vary the transformation ratio, that is, the proportion between input voltage and output voltage. When the contact is positioned at a specific point along the winding, the output voltage corresponds to a fraction of the input voltage. During operation, when the input voltage changes, the magnetic field generated around the winding varies accordingly, influencing the induced voltage in the winding itself. This allows precise control of the output voltage, which can be used to power electronic devices, test circuits, or equipment with unknown operating conditions.

Differences compared to a rheostat and a dimmer

The variac is an autotransformer with an adjustable tap, allowing the output voltage to be varied continuously from zero up to the maximum value. It is a reactive device, meaning it does not dissipate significant power, aside from core losses.

The rheostat is a resistive component with variable resistance, typically consisting of a wire wound around an insulating core and a sliding contact that adjusts the length of the resistive path through which current flows. Since a rheostat is a variable resistor, it dissipates power in the form of heat. The output voltage from a rheostat depends on the load and the current flowing through the circuit.

The dimmer, also known as a light intensity controller, is a device used to control the power delivered to resistive loads such as lamps. Modern dimmers are often implemented as switching devices that periodically interrupt the AC sine wave. This process, called waveform chopping, allows the light intensity to be varied. However, since dimmers introduce interruptions in the waveform, they can generate noise and distortion, leading to possible electromagnetic interference.

In summary, a variac provides precise control of the output voltage without significant power dissipation, a rheostat controls current through resistance and dissipates power, while a dimmer controls light intensity through waveform chopping but may introduce noise and distortion.

What is the usefulness of a variac in a laboratory, even for hobby use?

Using a variac in the laboratory to gradually power devices that may be faulty or have just been repaired is a cautious and professional approach that helps reduce the risk of further damage. Here is how a variac can be effectively used in this scenario.

Gradual voltage increase: a variac allows supplying a very low initial voltage and then increasing it gradually, enabling devices to “wake up” progressively. This is particularly useful for equipment that may contain capacitors or components sensitive to sudden high voltage startup. Gradual voltage increase helps prevent excessive current surges that could damage aged internal components.

Detection of latent faults: if the device has residual faults or hidden issues, using a variac allows operators to observe any signs of malfunction during the voltage ramp-up phase. This may include abnormal heating of components, smoke, sparks, or other visible or audible anomalies. This way, intervention is possible before the fault worsens, allowing more accurate diagnosis and repair.

Stability evaluation: after a repair or maintenance, it is important to evaluate the stability and overall behavior of the device. Using a variac, it is possible to gradually test different voltage ranges and assess how the device responds under various conditions. This helps identify any remaining issues or weaknesses in the circuit.

Risk minimization: using a variac significantly reduces the risk of accidental damage to repaired or newly assembled devices. In case of a fault or short circuit, the operator can quickly cut power by lowering the voltage with the variac, minimizing potential damage.

Ultimately, using a variac in a laboratory to gradually power potentially faulty or newly repaired devices provides a cautious and effective approach to safely evaluate and test their operation. It is a recommended practice for those aiming to identify issues and ensure reliable operation after repairs or maintenance.

Variac safety

A fundamental aspect to consider is that, like other autotransformers, a variac does not provide any galvanic isolation between the primary and secondary circuits. Therefore, it is essential to proceed with caution when using this device. Careful handling is required to ensure both operator safety and the integrity of connected circuits. If galvanic isolation is required, an isolation transformer can be added before or after the variac. This component provides an additional level of protection and safety.

Building an advanced variac starting from a basic variac purchased online

These variacs, typically rated around 2000 watts, can be purchased from platforms such as Amazon, eBay, and other electronics suppliers at affordable prices, generally around €50. However, one might wonder why these options may not be sufficient.

This article explores the process of transforming a basic commercial variac into a powerful and safe controlled power source for laboratory use. The starting point is a simple variac equipped only with a front-panel voltmeter and banana terminals for connection to the 230V mains and output.

Here is my schematic:

The mains input is protected by a 16A circuit breaker, which acts both as the main switch and as a safety measure in case of an unlikely but potentially severe short circuit. An indicator lamp signals when power is active. The variac follows as the core of the system. Immediately after it, a 4A circuit breaker is installed to protect the variac from overloads exceeding its maximum current capability.

Why use a 4A breaker to protect a 6A load? It is important to understand that circuit breakers may not always be very sensitive or fast in emergency conditions. Initially, a 6A breaker was used, but testing with a heater showed it did not trip even at about 7A. This is partly due to tolerances and the time required for the thermal element to react, which can take several minutes. During this delay, a device under test with non-critical faults could overheat or pose a fire risk.

After several tests, a 4A breaker proved more suitable. In a test where the load was gradually increased to about 6A, it tripped in about 30 seconds, as shown in the attached video. This approach ensures a safer and more reliable operating environment.

After the circuit breaker, an additional protection system is implemented using a fuse. This is intended to protect low-power devices, such as vintage radios, which might not trigger a 6A breaker even in case of a fault.

The fuse holder allows different current ratings to be used depending on the load. For higher power loads, the fuse can be bypassed using a parallel switch, leaving the circuit breaker as the primary protection.

A pilot lamp in parallel with the fuse indicates if it has blown. A switch is also included to disconnect the earth from the front panel outlets. This can be useful for certain oscilloscope measurements under specific conditions.

Below you can see the DIN sockets used. They are from different brands but function perfectly.

Initially, a metal enclosure was considered, but finding one with the required dimensions proved difficult. Therefore, a wooden enclosure was chosen to fit the workspace exactly. However, anyone replicating this project should preferably use a metal enclosure connected to earth.

In the schematic, analog voltmeter and ammeter are shown. In the actual build, a Vemer EV2M-R panel meter was used for higher precision, capable of measuring current in 10mA increments. It is separately powered, allowing accurate readings starting from 0V.

The EV2M-R is powered from the mains before the variac. For correct wiring, refer to the manufacturer’s datasheet.

Small demonstration with a light bulb

If you want to read more about variacs, visit https://www.audiovalvole.it/variac.html

Continue reading...

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Stabilized Anode Power Supply 0–350V 5–50mA

When experimenting with vacuum tube circuits on the workbench, one of the most useful tools to have is a reliable and adjustable anode power supply. Unfortunately many people end up improvising with makeshift supplies, old transformers, dropping resistors and other temporary solutions that may work, but are neither practical nor safe. After years of doing tests this way, I decided to build a small bench power supply specifically dedicated to vacuum tube experimentation.

The idea was to obtain a simple but robust instrument capable of delivering an adjustable anode voltage up to 350V, with overload protection and stability sufficient for use during circuit development and testing. At the same time I did not want a complicated design full of rare or difficult to source components. On the contrary, the goal was to build something that could use common parts, easily recovered even from old equipment.

The project presented here was born exactly with this philosophy: a tube regulated power supply intended as a laboratory tool for hobbyists and for anyone who enjoys experimenting with vacuum tube electronics. It is not meant to be elegant or minimalist, but rather practical, robust and tolerant of the inevitable mistakes that happen when testing circuits still under development.

Useful tool for experimentation

As I mentioned in my previous article about the transistor curve tracer, I owned an old Chinaglia oscilloscope with a CRT that was already exhausted and not worth repairing. Since I am the kind of person who never throws anything away, I immediately dismantled it to recover some components, mainly tubes and tube sockets. Then, while I was throwing the remaining parts into the box for disposal, I had the idea of salvaging the entire chassis and turning it into a small anode power supply that could be useful when experimenting with circuits on the bench, also replacing an old bulky power supply that I had built many years ago when I was still a beginner.

I started sketching a circuit that could work well with simple and inexpensive components. As the regulating tube I chose a 6GE5 (a very robust compactron TV horizontal output tube), and as the error amplifier a very common EF80. I also included, partly for the pleasure of using them, three 85A2 gas regulators: one stabilizes the screen voltage of the 6GE5 while the other two, connected in series, provide the two negative voltages required for the EF80 biasing. There is also a comparator circuit built around a TL081 opamp which monitors the current drawn from the power supply output and, in case of overload (adjustable), disconnects the screen grid supply of the 6GE5 forcing the tube into cutoff. A push button allows the normal operation of the power supply to be restored. As the title suggests, the output voltage can be freely adjusted from 0 up to 350V, while another potentiometer allows adjustment of the protection circuit sensitivity within a range between 5 and 50mA. I also added a 6.3V 1A AC output, protected simply by a fuse.

Someone might ask why I did not build it using solid state devices instead of tubes. The answer is simple: it is actually easier this way. Solid state designs require extremely fast protection circuits because transistors can fail in a fraction of a millisecond, while good old vacuum tubes are much more tolerant. If for a brief moment they deliver a bit more current than expected, they usually do not care at all. The second reason is that with tubes there is no need to search for and mount large heat sinks. And finally, the last reason is that I simply like tubes and I enjoy using them. Now let’s take a look at the schematic of the power supply, click to enlarge:

–> Download the schematic by clicking here alimentatore-6GE5.zip <–

The following photos show my construction…

In operation

Since the oscilloscope cabinet is almost completely sealed, in order to prevent the inside from turning into a small oven I drilled a hole on the side and installed a cooling fan (I will also need to add a grille so nobody can accidentally stick their fingers inside) and drilled several ventilation holes on the top above the power tube. In this way the fan pushes fresh air into the cabinet while the hot air escapes from the top.

What is the difference between a simply adjustable power supply and a stabilized one? On the internet you can find many schematics for anode power supplies, both tube and transistor based, but a large portion of them are actually only adjustable supplies. In these circuits there is a potentiometer that allows you to vary the output voltage, but the selected value does not remain truly stable. The voltage changes with the load and is also affected by the normal fluctuations of the mains supply. In practice this type of regulation is rather crude.

In a stabilized power supply the situation is different, because a circuit called an error amplifier is used. In my project this function is performed by the EF80. The role of the error amplifier is to continuously compare the output voltage with a reference voltage and correct it in real time so that the selected value remains constant regardless of variations in the mains supply or in the current drawn by the powered circuit.

However it is important to clarify a rather common misunderstanding: the presence of zener diodes or gas regulators does not automatically make a power supply stabilized. I have seen several DIY amplifier builds where, for example, a 6080 tube was used together with a gas regulator between grid and ground to supply a 300B. In theory it should behave as a regulator, but in practice the 6080 ends up providing only a “more or less” controlled voltage that continuously drifts. When you analyze the circuit behavior carefully you often realize that the entire stage could be replaced by a simple dropping resistor with practically the same result, sometimes even better.

Continue reading...

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.